In Case You've Wondered

My blog is where my wandering thoughts are interspersed with stuff I made up. So, if while reading you find yourself confused about the context, don't feel alone. I get confused, too.

If you're here for the stories, I started another blog: scratchingforchange.blogspot.com

One other thing: sometimes I write words you refuse to use in front of children, or polite company, unless you have a flat tire, or hit your thumb with a hammer.

I don't use them to offend; I use them to embellish.

jescordwaineratgmail.com
Showing posts with label Automobile Woes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Automobile Woes. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Bafflement Leads To Knowledge

Last week, while driving, my car started misfiring, and the check engine light started flashing. I made it home to a parts house, they found some codes. The codes said two cylinders were misfiring, and all were misfiring randomly. I asked the parts manager if it could be bad fuel, since I had filled the car that morning. They said it could, so I bought a bottle of a fuel conditioner that helps with bad fuel. I put the bottle in the tank, drove home, and called the dealer. I was told the soonest I could make an appointment was in a week. Discouraged I made the appointment. My short conversation revealed some ball-park prices for what it might be, and I wasn't happy.

The next morning, the car started fine, the check engine light was off, and a short test drive revealed the car was now running fine. I went to the local parts house, bought another bottle of the fuel treatment, and asked one of the workers if they heard anything about bad fuel being sold in the area. They mentioned two reports they heard, and one of the reports was where I've been buying my gas. I put the treatment in the tank, and drove home. Still, there was no misfire, and checking the fuel mileage revealed the fuel mileage hadn't changed. Driving it during the week led to some occasional misfires, which last for only a moment, and then the car ran fine.

 During the last week, I've been researching different subjects, and watching videos by experts (are they really experts?) and soaking in the information.

The consensus is the misfiring is either bad fuel, worn plugs, or failing coil packs. Bad fuel - if it's really bad - requires draining the tank, and maybe, some expensive repairs of replacing the internal tank fuel filter, and replacing the fuel pump. Due to how fast the car recovered from the event, I'm thinking that if the fuel is contaminated with water, or has an octane problem, changing stations, filling with good fuel, and some more fuel conditioner will line out the problem.

Research showed the intended life of the spark plugs is 90,000 miles. They can fail at the mileage of 58,000 miles, which is the mileage on the car, but that isn't common. Considering that the engine code showed two cylinders misfiring, and random misfires of all cylinders, that doesn't seem to be the problem. Spark plugs usually don't fail in such numbers, and don't "bounce back" after resting.

Coil packs can fail earlier than the 90,000 miles intended. Like the spark plugs, they might fail early, but why two, and then all randomly, and the next day they're fine? I can see where engine heat would eventually cause the packs to start having problems, but unless the coil packs were part of a bad batch installed by the manufacturers, such failures wouldn't be common. There are no reports of the problem I had for the engine that is installed. 

The dealer stated the cost to just diagnose the car is $205, with the diagnostic cost removed if repairs are done. That seemed excessive, so I researched that too. Dealers make a substantial amount of their annual profits with repairs. The profit is way more than the profit from new vehicles, and parts can be marked up 125%. That, to me, means the incentive of a dealer is to soak you with the diagnostics, lead you to believe many repairs are needed, and laugh all the way to the bank. Maybe I'm wrong, but considering the reputation of auto dealers, there is something to my suspicion. 

So, I'm somewhat at a quandary. I can change the plugs, and the coil packs, myself at a cost of around $200. It's about an hour project, and the only problem I might face is if I use aftermarket coil packs. According to what I've read, some mechanics recommend only using OEM coil packs, which leads to $500 for the four cylinders of my car. Even parts house aftermarket coil packs are near that price, but online, I can get four from a reputable aftermarket manufacturer for $125. With the addition of plugs, and a decent torque wrench (which I don't have), the cost is the $200.  The same work quoted by the dealer is $750. 

I'm debating my thoughts about what I should do. One thought is to just add some more fuel conditioner, and avoiding the filling station I've been using. If that works, I've spent less than $20 dollars on the fuel conditioner, and I should be good for over at least 30,000 miles.

Another thought is to replace the plugs first to see if that solves the problem. Adding changing the coil packs isn't a huge additional cost, but to change the plugs, the coil packs are removed first, which allows me time to check, but at that point, why not just change them all? If one shows higher resistance, I can toss it, and have the others for backups.

This is where I am. I still have the appointment with the dealers. I know I'll be faced with some higher costs, and my cynical mind says I'll get soaked. The dealer does have their reputation to consider, but so do drug dealers, and attorneys. I'll make a decision today, and pray it's the right decision.